Summary
Starmer’s meeting with Meloni in Rome aimed to explore how Italy has managed to reduce irregular migration by 60% compared to the previous year, primarily through tough enforcement and international cooperation. While he acknowledged Italy’s achievements in combating smuggling and enhancing border control, critics, including humanitarian organizations, have cautioned that these policies may not translate effectively to the U.K. context. They argue that focusing on deterrence without creating safe and legal pathways for refugees could lead to more tragedies, as seen in the Channel. The juxtaposition of Starmer’s pragmatic approach to immigration against the backdrop of rising fatalities at sea has sparked debate within his party and among advocacy groups about the moral implications of adopting such policies.
Context of Starmer’s Visit
Starmer’s visit follows a weekend where multiple migrant deaths highlighted the dangers of crossing the Channel. More than 22,000 migrants have made this perilous journey in 2024, with tragic incidents occurring regularly. The Labour leader’s interest in Italy’s model appears to be part of a broader strategy to address the immigration crisis in a way that resonates with voters concerned about border security. However, this has sparked discomfort among some members of the Labour Party, who view Meloni’s government as promoting hard-right populism.
Criticism of Migration Policies
Humanitarian organizations, including the International Rescue Committee, have criticized the adoption of Italy’s migration strategies, labeling them “costly and ultimately ineffective.” They advocate for the establishment of safe routes for refugees as a more humane and effective solution. The IRC’s acting executive director emphasized that prioritizing deterrent policies risks more lives, particularly given the recent fatalities in the Channel.
Ethical Considerations
Starmer’s alignment with Meloni’s policies raises ethical questions about the treatment of migrants and the potential violation of human rights. Critics argue that Italy’s agreements with countries like Tunisia and Albania, designed to deter migration, have led to abuses and inadequate protections for refugees. The British Home Secretary defended the government’s interest in Italy’s approach, asserting a moral obligation to combat human trafficking and organized crime, yet the broader implications of adopting such measures remain a contentious topic within U.K. politics.
UK leader Starmer seeks to learn from Meloni's tough migration policies at meeting in Rome
Sep. 16 / Gazette “ ROME (AP) — U.K. Prime Minister Keir Starmer met Italian Premier Giorgia Meloni in Rome on Monday, as the center-left British leader aimed to learn how her...
Italy’s ‘costly’ deterrent policies can’t save migrant lives in the UK, says charity
Sep. 16 / The Guardian “ Keir Starmer should drop the pursuit of Italy’s “costly and ultimately ineffective” migration deterrence policies if the UK is to put an end to people dying...
U.K. leader seeks to learn from Italy's tough migration policies at meeting in Rome
Sep. 16 / L.a. Times “ U.K. Prime Minister Keir Starmer met Italian Premier Giorgia Meloni in Rome on Monday, as the center-left British leader aimed to learn how her right-wing...
Starmer puts ‘pragmatism’ before perceptions in meeting with Meloni
Sep. 16 / The Guardian “ Some Labourites may see a hard-right populist but the British PM has an eye on the immigration policies of an ally
Cooper defends Labour examining Italy’s migrant policies – UK politics live
Sep. 16 / The Guardian “ Home secretary says Starmer’s visit part of ‘pursuing Britain’s interests’ but says Albania-style scheme not an option ‘at the moment’
UK PM Starmer seeks immigration lessons from Italy’s Meloni
Sep. 16 / Al Jazeera “ Keir Starmer’s meeting with the far-right premier in Rome branded ‘disturbing’. British Prime Minister Keir Starmer has met with his Italian counterpart,...