Summary
The presidential election is significantly influencing the debate surrounding the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and potential deregulation of health care in the United States. Candidates Kamala Harris and Donald Trump have contrasting views on health care policy, particularly regarding the ACA, which has provided coverage to millions of Americans since its enactment in 2010.
As the election approaches, health care has emerged as a crucial issue, with both candidates pledging to make it more affordable. Harris aims to expand and strengthen the ACA, advocating for the permanence of enhanced subsidies and the extension of Medicaid coverage to states that have not yet adopted the expansion. In contrast, Trump, alongside his running mate JD Vance, has suggested a deregulatory approach that could potentially undermine protections for individuals with preexisting conditions. Vance’s comments about “salvaging” the ACA have been met with skepticism, given the Republican Party’s historical attempts to repeal the law. The debate is further complicated by the candidates’ differing strategies for managing health care costs and access, with Harris focusing on maintaining existing protections and Trump proposing a yet-to-be-defined plan that critics fear may lead to increased costs and reduced coverage for vulnerable populations.
Harris’s Position on the ACA
Kamala Harris has consistently supported the ACA, emphasizing its role in providing health care coverage to millions of Americans. She has proposed making temporary enhancements to the ACA permanent, particularly the subsidies that help lower the cost of premiums for many households. In recent debates, Harris has framed her health care agenda as a commitment to protecting and expanding access to affordable health care, countering Trump’s claims that he has a viable plan to replace the ACA.
Trump’s Health Care Strategy
Donald Trump has historically opposed the ACA, attempting to repeal it during his presidency. While he claims to have “concepts of a plan” to replace the ACA, details remain vague, leading to skepticism about the feasibility of his proposals. Trump’s running mate, JD Vance, has suggested that deregulating health care markets could offer more choices but may also threaten essential protections for those with preexisting conditions. This approach raises concerns about the potential for increased costs and decreased access to necessary health care services for many Americans.
The Impact of Deregulation
The potential deregulation of health care under a Trump administration could fundamentally alter the landscape of health insurance in the U.S. Critics argue that separating individuals into high-risk pools—an idea floated by Vance—could lead to higher premiums for those with chronic conditions, effectively making health care unaffordable for many. Proponents of the ACA maintain that the current system, which pools risk across a wide range of enrollees, is essential for keeping health care costs manageable. The ongoing debate highlights the stark contrast between the candidates’ visions for health care and the implications for millions of Americans as the election nears.
Presidential election puts Affordable Care Act back in the bull's-eye
Oct. 25 / Abc News / This KFF Health News article emphasizes the stakes of the election for the ACA and health coverage. It provides valuable insights from health experts, making it a comprehensive overview of the current health care landscape. “ This is a KFF Health News story . Health care is suddenly front and center in the final sprint to the presidential election, and the outcome will shape the...
Drug costs, abortion, Obamacare: How Trump and Harris could change U.S. health care
Oct. 19 / Cnbc / CNBC outlines stark contrasts in Harris's and Trump's health care policies, emphasizing the implications for voters. The analysis is clear and informative, providing a well-rounded view of both candidates' approaches. “ President Donald Trump talks to the press outside the White House, July 19, 2019, left, and Democratic presidential nominee and U.S. Vice President Kamala...
Here are 4 campaign promises from Harris. What are their chances if she wins?
Oct. 16 / L.a. Times / The L.A. Times examines Harris's campaign promises, exploring their feasibility if elected. The article is thorough and raises important questions about legislative challenges, though it could be more concise. “ As she runs the most truncated presidential campaign in modern American history, Vice President Kamala Harris has made lofty promises on issues that polls...
5 times when Kamala Harris changed her stance on an issue
Oct. 10 / L.a. Times / The L.A. Times discusses Harris's shifting stance on various issues, including health care. It effectively highlights the complexities of her political evolution, but it could benefit from a more focused narrative. “ Vice President Kamala Harris struggled to define herself when she ran for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomination. The party’s base was demanding that...
Clarence Page: Donald Trump ‘saved’ Obamcare? Now that’s a whopper.
Oct. 6 / Chicago Tribune / Clarence Page critiques the irony of Trump and Vance's claims about "saving" the ACA, effectively highlighting the Republican record of opposition to the law. The analysis is sharp and insightful, offering historical context. “ Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, it is said. And in Washington, so is stealing credit. Is there a better example than Republican lawmakers...
Kamala Harris Edges Ahead in Pennsylvania With Trump Pollster
Oct. 1 / Newsweek / Newsweek reports on Harris's lead in Pennsylvania, highlighting key demographics. The polling data provides valuable context for understanding voter sentiment, though it lacks deeper analysis of health care implications. “ Vice President has a three-point lead over former President in the battleground state of Pennsylvania according to a survey conducted by two pollsters—one...
Harris launches multimillion-dollar TV ad blitz hitting Trump's 'concepts of a plan' for health care
Oct. 1 / Nbc News / Harris's ad blitz effectively highlights Trump's vague health care proposals, leveraging polling data to frame the ACA as a lifeline for millions. The ad's targeted approach in battleground states adds strategic depth. “ WASHINGTON — Kamala Harris is launching a seven-figure ad blitz about health care targeting Donald Trump’s calls to replace the Affordable Care Act with a...
Vance claims Trump tried to 'salvage' Obamacare, but he tried to kill it
Oct. 2 / Dailykos / Oliver Willis counters Vance's assertion that Trump salvaged Obamacare by detailing Trump's attempts to repeal it. The article is straightforward and effectively dismantles misleading claims, making it a solid resource for voters. “ In an exchange about health care during the vice presidential debate on CBS Tuesday night, Sen. JD Vance claimed that Donald Trump took action to “salvage”...
How Kamala Harris’ policy views have changed since she first ran for president
Sep. 29 / Courant / A thorough examination of Harris's evolving health care stance reveals significant shifts toward centrist policies since 2019. The analysis underscores the political implications of her changes amid the current election landscape. “ DETROIT — When Vice President Kamala Harris sought the presidency five years ago, she supported overhauling the nation’s health care system and endorsed...
We know what Trump's 'concepts of a plan' on health care would be. They would be deadly
Sep. 26 / Newsday / Michael Hiltzik critiques Trump's vague health care "concepts," effectively exposing the potential dangers of deregulation. The article is well-researched and offers a compelling argument against proposed changes. “ Michael Hiltzik is a columnist for the Los Angeles Times. Former President Donald Trump's claim at his debate with Vice President Kamala Harris that he has...
Bill Ellis: Kamala Harris wins presidential debate
Sep. 27 / Boulder Daily Camera / Bill Ellis applauds Harris's debate performance while noting her evolving positions. The article captures the dynamic of the campaign and offers a balanced view, though it could benefit from more critical analysis of Harris's shifts. “ In a surprising outcome, Vice President Kamala Harris spoke forcefully against her opponent on Sept. 10. Missing was the typical bullying we have seen in Mr....
Sep. 21 / New York Post / Victor Nava and Amy Sikma explore Harris's shift from advocating for Medicare for All to supporting the ACA. The piece raises important questions about political consistency, though it could delve deeper into implications. “ MADISON, Wis. – Vice President Kamala Harris, who campaigned on abolishing private health plans in 2019, charged Friday that it is former President Donald...