Summary
Marjorie Taylor Greene has faced significant backlash for her controversial remarks regarding Hurricane Helene and the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) response. She has suggested that the government can control the weather and implied that Democrats manipulated the hurricanes to target Republican strongholds, which has drawn criticism from both political opponents and some fellow Republicans.
In the wake of Hurricane Helene, Greene’s social media posts claimed that the Democrats were responsible for directing the storm towards red states, asserting, “Yes they can control the weather. It’s ridiculous for anyone to lie and say it can’t be done.” This statement, along with her unfounded claims that FEMA was diverting hurricane relief funds to assist illegal immigrants, has prompted condemnation from various quarters. Former GOP Congressman Denver Riggleman criticized Greene’s supporters for enabling her rhetoric, labeling it as a mix of “superstition, religion, and ignorance.” Additionally, some Republican colleagues have publicly rebuked her, emphasizing that humans cannot control weather patterns. Greene’s comments have not only sparked outrage but have also been linked to the broader political discourse surrounding climate change and disaster response in the context of the upcoming elections.
Political Fallout
Greene’s remarks have resulted in a fractious environment among House Republicans, with some members outright rejecting her claims. Representative Carlos Gimenez stated, “NEW FLASH —> Humans cannot create or control hurricanes,” while others expressed frustration over her influence within the party. This internal conflict highlights the challenges faced by the GOP as they navigate the implications of Greene’s statements in the context of their electoral strategy.
Fundraising Amid Controversy
Despite the backlash, Greene’s fundraising efforts have surged, raising $2.17 million in 2024, significantly more than in previous election cycles. Her campaign slogan, “Save America, Stop Communism,” and alignment with former President Donald Trump continue to resonate with a segment of the Republican base, suggesting that her controversial stance may not hinder her electoral prospects in Georgia’s 14th Congressional District.
Broader Implications
The discourse surrounding Greene’s comments reflects a larger trend of politicizing natural disasters and emergency responses. Critics argue that such rhetoric can undermine public trust in government agencies like FEMA, especially during critical times when accurate information is vital for effective disaster management. As the political landscape evolves ahead of the elections, the interplay between climate discourse, misinformation, and electoral strategies will remain a focal point of concern.
Marjorie Taylor Greene Is Raising More Money Than Ever
Oct. 14 / Newsweek / Greene's fundraising success is highlighted, showcasing her appeal despite controversy. The article effectively contrasts her campaign with her opponent's, providing context for her political strategy and resilience. “ Georgia Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene raised more money this year than in her last two election years, according to the latest Federal Election...
Falsehoods regarding hurricane response put character flaws on full display | Column
Oct. 12 / Pennlive / Pennlive offers a thoughtful analysis of political cowardice in the face of crisis, drawing parallels to historical events. Its depth and personal experience lend credibility, but it risks losing some readers with its length. “ Ernest Hemingway wrote that courage is grace under pressure. The corollary to that, of course, is that cowardice is weakness in the face of danger. On the...
"Loony tunes": House GOP infighting erupts over Marjorie Taylor Greene's hurricane comments
Oct. 10 / Axios / Axios provides a concise overview of Republican infighting spurred by Greene's comments, highlighting dissent within the party. The direct quotes from various representatives enhance its authority and relevance to current events. “ Even while they are scattered across the country campaigning for reelection in the final weeks before Nov. 5, House Republicans are still, somehow, at each...
DeSantis takes fresh pot shot at Harris after Hurricane Milton strikes
Oct. 10 / New York Daily News / New York Daily News captures DeSantis's political maneuvering during disaster response, emphasizing the ongoing partisan tensions. The article succinctly illustrates the implications of political gamesmanship in crisis situations. “ Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis took a fresh pot shot at Vice President Kamala Harris on Thursday on the morning after Hurricane Milton ripped through the state....
Ex-GOP congressman rips Marjorie Taylor Greene voters: You’re to blame
Oct. 9 / Nj / Riggleman's commentary strikes hard at Greene's supporters, blending humor with a serious critique of political ignorance. While engaging, it may come off as overly harsh, potentially limiting its audience's receptiveness. “ Former GOP Congressman Denver Riggleman blames the fringes of the Republican Party for sending Marjorie Taylor Greene to Washington and thus giving her a...
Trump-Vance hurricane/FEMA disinformation: Darcy cartoon
Oct. 10 / Cleveland / Cleveland's piece creatively employs satire to critique Greene's claims and the broader misinformation surrounding hurricane responses, making it a compelling read. However, it may alienate some readers with its tone. “ CLEVELAND, Ohio -- In between hurricanes Helene and Milton, hurricanes Marjorie, JD, Donald and Mar-a-Lie-Go struck spreading destructive disinformation and...