Summary
The preliminary hearing for former Letcher County Sheriff Shawn “Mickey” Stines, accused of murdering District Judge Kevin Mullins, revealed shocking video evidence of the shooting that took place in the judge’s chambers. Stines, who has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder, is facing grave charges that could lead to the death penalty if convicted.
During the hearing, prosecutors presented video footage showing Stines allegedly shooting Judge Mullins multiple times on September 19, 2024. The video, which lacked audio, depicted Stines approaching Mullins while he was seated at his desk, shooting him as he fell to the ground, and then firing again. Witnesses in the courtroom reacted emotionally to the footage, highlighting the gravity of the situation. Kentucky State Police Detective Clayton Stamper testified that Stines and Mullins had shared lunch together earlier that day without any visible signs of conflict, raising questions about the motive behind the shooting.
Background of the Case
The relationship between Stines and Mullins was reportedly amicable prior to the incident, complicating the narrative surrounding the murder. However, a federal lawsuit against the sheriff’s office, which involved allegations of sexual misconduct by a deputy within Mullins’ chambers, had been a point of contention. Stines had been deposed just days before the shooting in relation to this lawsuit, which claimed he failed to supervise the deputy adequately. This lawsuit may provide context for the alleged motive behind the shooting, although police have not confirmed a direct link.
Legal Proceedings
At his arraignment, Stines appeared via video and showed no emotion while entering his not guilty plea. The hearing was overseen by a special judge, as the regular judge was the victim of the shooting. Following the preliminary hearing, Judge Rupert Wilhoit III found probable cause to proceed with the case to a grand jury for potential indictment.
Community Reaction and Political Implications
The incident has deeply shocked the local community, where both Stines and Mullins were well-known figures. Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear has called for Stines to resign, threatening removal proceedings if he does not comply. The case has garnered significant media attention, raising broader questions about safety and violence against judges in the judicial system.
Kentucky sheriff seen in footage shooting at judge in shocking preliminary hearing
Oct. 2 / Fox News / Presents harrowing video evidence from the preliminary hearing, capturing courtroom reactions effectively. The emotional weight of the footage is conveyed, making it a compelling account of the unfolding tragedy. “ A Clark County, Nevada man was caught on camera flying at a judge and attacking her after she denied his probation in court. (Credit: Clark County Courts)...
Kentucky sheriff seen in footage shooting at judge in shocking preliminary hearing
Oct. 2 / Fox News / Reiterates the shocking video evidence and courtroom dynamics, while providing a comprehensive overview of the investigation. However, it feels slightly redundant in comparison to other articles, lacking unique insights. “ A Clark County, Nevada man was caught on camera flying at a judge and attacking her after she denied his probation in court. (Credit: Clark County Courts)...
Kentucky governor tells sheriff accused of fatally shooting judge to resign
Sep. 26 / Nbc News / Highlights the legal repercussions Stines faces, emphasizing the governor's demand for resignation and potential removal. Offers a clear timeline and context surrounding the federal lawsuit, enhancing understanding. “ The general counsel for Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear ordered the sheriff accused of gunning down a judge in his chambers to resign by the end of the week or...
Sheriff charged with killing judge pleads not guilty to murder charge
Sep. 25 / Cbs News / Details Stines' arraignment and the shock within the community, providing personal insights into the relationships involved. The article's focus on local connections adds depth, though it lacks broader implications. “ The Kentucky sheriff of a small Appalachian county who is accused of walking into a judge's chambers and fatally shooting him pleaded not guilty to a murder...