Summary
Erdogan’s response to the death of Fethullah Gulen, the exiled cleric accused of orchestrating a failed coup attempt in Turkey in 2016, reflects the ongoing political tensions between the two figures. In his remarks, Erdogan characterized Gulen’s death as a “dishonorable death,” reaffirming his long-standing view of Gulen as a terrorist and vowing to continue efforts to eliminate the Gulenist movement.
The relationship between Erdogan and Gulen has been tumultuous, transitioning from alliance to bitter rivalry. Gulen’s movement initially supported Erdogan’s rise to power but became a target after a fallout that led to accusations of corruption and political maneuvering. Following the 2016 coup attempt, which resulted in significant loss of life and political instability, Erdogan’s government enacted widespread crackdowns on Gulen’s followers, leading to thousands of arrests and purges in various sectors, including the military and education. Erdogan’s latest comments emphasize his view that Gulen escaped justice in life, but he claims that divine retribution awaits. This rhetoric underscores the deep-seated animosity that continues to shape Turkish politics and the narrative surrounding the coup attempt and its aftermath.
Political Context
-
Coup Attempt Background: The July 15, 2016, coup attempt resulted in the deaths of 251 people and injuries to over 2,000. Erdogan accused Gulen of masterminding the insurrection, a claim Gulen vehemently denied, stating that he had no role in the events.
-
Aftermath and Repression: Following the coup, Erdogan’s administration launched a significant crackdown on individuals and institutions associated with Gulen, closing schools, media outlets, and businesses, and arresting thousands. This period marked a shift towards more authoritarian governance in Turkey, consolidating Erdogan’s power.
-
International Implications: Gulen’s exile in the U.S. and Turkey’s demands for his extradition have strained U.S.-Turkey relations, with the U.S. government requiring substantial evidence before considering extradition. Erdogan’s comments on Gulen’s death may serve to reinforce his domestic narrative of a relentless fight against perceived threats to the state, while also appealing to nationalist sentiments among his supporters.
Erdogan’s rhetoric following Gulen’s death not only reflects personal animosity but also serves as a political tool to solidify his base and justify ongoing repressive measures against dissenting voices in Turkey.
US-based Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen dead at 83
Oct. 21 / Al Jazeera / A brief report on Gulen's passing, providing essential background on his relationship with Erdogan. While it captures the fundamental facts, it lacks the analytical depth present in more comprehensive articles, leaving readers wanting more. “ A former ally of President Erdogan, Gulen was accused of masterminding a failed a coup in 2016 and lived in exile. Turkish Muslim cleric Fethullah Gulen, who...
Coup Attempt by Gulen Allies Led Erdogan to Crack Down in Turkey
Oct. 22 / The New York Times / Gall's article offers a thorough exploration of the Erdogan-Gulen dynamic, tracing their alliance's evolution into rivalry. It provides valuable context on the coup attempt and subsequent crackdowns, enriching the narrative significantly. “ President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Fethullah Gulen, the powerful preacher who died this week, began as allies. But their falling out brought bloodshed and an...
Erdogan says the cleric accused of orchestrating a 2016 coup attempt had a 'dishonorable death'
Oct. 22 / Abc News / Erdogan's remarks on Gulen's death are presented with vivid language, emphasizing the deep animosity and political stakes involved. It effectively highlights Erdogan's ongoing campaign against Gulen's followers, making it a crucial piece for understanding current Turkish politics. “ ISTANBUL -- Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan responded Tuesday to the death of exiled Islamic cleric Fetullah Gulen , accused by Turkey of...
Erdogan says the cleric accused of orchestrating a 2016 coup attempt had a 'dishonorable death'
Oct. 22 / Abc News / This piece mirrors the first in content and structure, reiterating Erdogan's condemnatory tone towards Gulen. While informative, it lacks unique insights, making it less compelling compared to other articles that delve deeper into the implications of Gulen's death. “ ISTANBUL -- Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan responded Tuesday to the death of exiled Islamic cleric Fetullah Gulen , accused by Turkey of...
Fethullah Gulen, Exiled Cleric Accused by Turkey of Attempted Coup, Dies in U.S.
Oct. 21 / Wsj / Coverage of Gulen's death is concise, focusing on his denial of coup involvement and historical context. However, it lacks depth regarding the political ramifications and Erdogan's reaction, making it less informative than others. “ The reclusive cleric denied orchestrating the short-lived insurrection against President Recep Tayyip Erdogan that brought tanks onto the streets.
Fethullah Gulen, Muslim cleric and target of Turkey’s Erdogan, dies at 83
Oct. 21 / The Washington Post / Tharoor's coverage succinctly captures the essence of Gulen's legacy and Erdogan's accusations. It balances factual reporting with historical context, making it a well-rounded piece that enhances understanding of the ongoing political conflict. “ Turkish authorities accused him of being the mastermind behind a 2016 coup attempt to topple the government of President Recep Tayyip Erdogan.