Summary
Smartmatic, a voting technology company, is pursuing a defamation lawsuit against the right-wing news network Newsmax, alleging that the network knowingly aired false claims about its involvement in rigging the 2020 presidential election. The trial is set to begin on September 30, 2024, following a Delaware judge’s ruling that the case should proceed to jury trial, allowing for the examination of whether Newsmax acted with actual malice in its reporting.
The lawsuit stems from claims made by Newsmax that Smartmatic’s software was manipulated to alter election results in favor of President Biden, despite Smartmatic’s equipment only being used in Los Angeles during the election. Smartmatic argues that these allegations have severely damaged its reputation and business, leading to significant financial losses. The judge has determined that while some statements made by Newsmax regarding Smartmatic are factually false, the jury will ultimately decide whether the network acted with reckless disregard for the truth. Notably, the judge ruled that Smartmatic will not be able to seek punitive damages unless it can demonstrate that Newsmax acted with express malice, which the court found lacking in evidence.
Background of the Case
Smartmatic’s lawsuit is part of a broader trend where several election technology companies, including Dominion Voting Systems, have taken legal action against media outlets for spreading misinformation about the 2020 election. These lawsuits highlight the ongoing legal and reputational repercussions faced by media companies that reported on allegations of election fraud without sufficient evidence.
Legal Proceedings
The upcoming trial will focus on multiple key issues, including whether Newsmax’s reporting constituted neutral and disinterested journalism or if it was a deliberate effort to mislead the public. A significant aspect of the trial will involve examining the credibility of the claims made about Smartmatic’s ties to foreign entities and whether these statements were made in a context that could be considered newsworthy.
Implications for Newsmax
The outcome of the trial could have dire financial implications for Newsmax, which is described as being in a precarious position financially. The network has previously settled a defamation lawsuit with Dominion Voting Systems for $787 million, a settlement that has set a precedent for high-stakes litigation in this arena. Newsmax’s defense hinges on the argument that it was merely reporting on allegations made by prominent figures, including former President Trump and his legal team, and that such reporting falls under First Amendment protections.
Conclusion
As the trial approaches, both parties prepare for a pivotal moment that could redefine the boundaries of journalistic responsibility and the repercussions of spreading misinformation in the political landscape. The case not only addresses the specific claims against Newsmax but also reflects broader concerns about media accountability in the context of the 2020 election and its aftermath.
Everything You Need to Know About Voting in the 2024 Election
Oct. 3 / Time / Provides a comprehensive overview of voting logistics for the 2024 election, addressing voter registration and early voting. The clarity and organization make it a valuable resource for navigating election processes. “ he will give voters the chance to decide on not just the next President, but also members of Congress, ballot measures, state representatives, governors, and...
Morning Report — Taking the temperature of the 2024 race
Sep. 30 / The Hill / Offers a snapshot of the current political landscape leading up to the 2024 election. While not deeply focused on the Smartmatic case, it provides a timely context for understanding the broader electoral environment. “ In today’s issue: Taking the temperature of the 2024 race The Election Day countdown: 36 days until Nov. 5. With just over a month until voters cast their...
Sep. 30 / Pr Newswire / Reports on public sentiment regarding the 2024 election's impact on personal finances. It offers unique survey data that highlights the economic stakes for voters, providing a different angle on electoral engagement. “ New research from Empower reveals the ways people are invested in politics this year GREENWOOD VILLAGE, Colo. , Sept. 30, 2024 /PRNewswire/ -- Beyond the...
Sep. 26 / Pr Newswire / Delivers an insightful analysis of how the 2024 election outcomes could affect agricultural policies. It stands out by focusing on sector-specific implications, making it relevant for businesses in agriculture. “ CINCINNATI , Sept. 25, 2024 /PRNewswire/ -- The Directions Group (formerly Aimpoint Research) has released a comprehensive report on the upcoming U.S....
Smartmatic Won’t Be Able To Collect Punitive Damages In Upcoming Newsmax Defamation Trial
Sep. 23 / Deadline / Explains the limitations placed on Smartmatic's potential damages, highlighting critical legal rulings. This piece is crucial for understanding the financial stakes involved and the legal framework guiding the trial. “ Smartmatic will not be able to collect punitive damages in its upcoming defamation trial against Newsmax should a jury rule in its favor, a Delaware judge...
Smartmatic’s defamation lawsuit against Newsmax is headed to trial. What’s at stake?
Sep. 22 / Courant / Highlights the legal stakes in Smartmatic's defamation trial against Newsmax, emphasizing the potential financial repercussions for the network. The article effectively contextualizes the case within broader media accountability issues. “ The 2024 presidential election is approaching, but the legal battle over how the 2020 race was covered by right-wing channel Newsmax isn’t going away...
Smartmatic's lawsuit against Newsmax over 2020 election reporting appears headed for trial
Sep. 13 / Home | Triblive.com / Summarizes the Smartmatic lawsuit against Newsmax, emphasizing the judge's findings on factual inaccuracies. It effectively sets the stage for the upcoming trial, making it a concise resource for legal developments. “ DOVER, Del. — A lawsuit pitting an electronic voting machine manufacturer that was targeted by allies of former President Donald Trump against a conservative...
Smartmatic's Suit Against Newsmax Over 2020 Election Lies Appears Headed For Trial
Sep. 13 / Huffpost / Covers the trial's imminent proceedings, providing a succinct summary of the key legal arguments. The article’s focus on the judge's rulings clarifies the trial's implications for media reporting standards. “ DOVER, Del. (AP) — A lawsuit pitting an electronic voting machine manufacturer that was targeted by allies of former President Donald Trump against a...
Newsmax faces defamation trial later this month over false claims that the 2020 election was rigged
Sep. 13 / Yahoo! News / Details the progression of Smartmatic's lawsuit against Newsmax, underlining the judge's rulings that favor Smartmatic. The article effectively captures the legal complexities and public interest surrounding the case. “ A Delaware judge ruled Thursday that the defamation lawsuit filed against the right-wing cable channel Newsmax by voting machine company should proceed to...
Newsmax wants to 'roll the bones' on taking false voting claims to court: Legal expert
Sep. 14 / Raw Story / Explores Newsmax's risky strategy in facing the defamation trial, backed by expert commentary. It raises important questions about media accountability, contributing to the ongoing discourse on misinformation. “ Right-wing cable news network Newsmax wants to take a chance on going to trial for voting equipment company Smartmatic's defamation suit — and it is unlikely...