Missed warnings in the investigation of Maine's deadliest mass shooting

In the months prior to the shooting, Card’s mental health deteriorated, leading to paranoid and delusional behavior, including threats of violence and the creation of a “hit list.” Reports indicate that over two dozen law enforcement officers were aware of his threats but lacked the legal means to remove his firearms. Investigations highlighted failures at various levels, including the Army’s disregard for mental health recommendations and the ineffective use of existing laws designed to prevent individuals with severe mental health issues from accessing weapons. The Maine state commission concluded that both military and civilian authorities missed vital opportunities to intervene, raising questions about the adequacy of protocols in place for handling such situations.

Key Findings

• Mental Health Decline: Card’s mental health issues were well-documented, with mental health providers recommending he not have access to firearms.

• Lack of Action: Despite warnings from military colleagues and family, law enforcement and military officials did not utilize available legal measures to intervene.

• Legal Framework: The investigation revealed shortcomings in the application of Maine’s yellow flag law, which allows temporary removal of firearms, as well as New York’s red flag laws, which were not pursued despite clear indications of risk.

Impact on Victims’ Families

The aftermath of the shooting has been devastating for the families of victims, many of whom are now seeking accountability through legal action against the Army. Survivors and family members express frustration over the systemic failures that allowed the tragedy to occur, emphasizing the need for better recognition of warning signs and more proactive measures to prevent similar incidents in the future.