Summary
In the wake of the Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization decision, there has been a notable increase in the scrutiny of pregnancy loss cases, leading to criminal prosecutions against women in various states. This trend reflects a growing legal environment where pregnancy-related outcomes, including miscarriages and stillbirths, are increasingly subject to investigation and potential criminal charges under laws that treat fetuses as persons.
Following the Dobbs ruling, many states have enacted or reinforced laws that not only restrict abortion access but also criminalize behaviors associated with pregnancy loss. Reports indicate that women have faced charges for actions perceived as neglectful or suspicious after experiencing a miscarriage or stillbirth. This includes investigations into their medical decisions and the handling of fetal remains, often driven by assumptions about their intentions regarding their pregnancies. For instance, cases have emerged where women were prosecuted for failing to seek timely medical care or for disposing of fetal remains in ways deemed inappropriate by law enforcement. Legal experts argue that these prosecutions are fueled by a societal tendency to blame women for pregnancy outcomes that do not align with traditional expectations of motherhood.
Legal and Societal Implications
The implications of these developments are significant, both legally and socially. The potential for criminal charges creates an atmosphere of fear among women who experience pregnancy loss, which may discourage them from seeking necessary medical care. The ambiguity in laws regarding pregnancy and fetal personhood can lead to inconsistent enforcement and a chilling effect on both patients and healthcare providers. For example, in states like South Carolina, Georgia, and Texas, women have faced severe consequences for actions taken during or after pregnancy loss, with reports highlighting cases where women were charged with crimes such as child neglect or even murder based on the circumstances surrounding their miscarriages.
Increased Investigations
The increase in investigations into pregnancy loss cases has raised concerns about the criminalization of women’s healthcare choices. Critics point out that many women already navigate the emotional and physical trauma of losing a pregnancy, and adding legal scrutiny only exacerbates their suffering. The legal landscape post-Dobbs has shifted from protecting reproductive rights to enforcing punitive measures against women, which may disproportionately affect marginalized communities who are less able to navigate these complex legal challenges.
Conclusion
As the legal environment continues to evolve, the intersection of reproductive rights, maternal health, and criminal justice raises critical questions about women’s autonomy and the implications of state laws on personal healthcare decisions. The trend towards prosecuting women for pregnancy-related outcomes may signal a broader societal shift that prioritizes punitive measures over compassionate healthcare and support for those experiencing pregnancy loss.
SC among states turning miscarriages and stillbirths into criminal cases against women
Oct. 31 / Postandcourier / Highlights the intersection of pregnancy loss and criminalization, detailing the chilling effect of increased scrutiny on women, and providing unique case studies that illustrate the broader implications of such laws. “ This article was published in partnership with The Marshall Project , a nonprofit news organization covering the U.S. criminal justice system. Sign up for...
Why Sen. Hassan Is Sharing Her Miscarriage Story 30 Years Later
Oct. 29 / Popsugar / Offers a personal narrative from Senator Hassan, reflecting on her miscarriage experience and advocating for reproductive rights, effectively connecting individual trauma to the larger political landscape post-Dobbs. “ New Hampshire Sen. Maggie Hassan has long been a fierce advocate for women's rights and working families. She was initially inspired to run for office to...
Oct. 23 / Independent / Delivers an investigative account of a woman's experience raising a child conceived through rape, shedding light on the barriers to abortion access and the socio-economic factors that complicate reproductive choices. “ This story is part of an investigative series and new documentary, The A-Word, by The Independent examining the state of abortion access and reproductive...
Why doctors won’t use legal abortion exceptions in 2024, despite rising deaths
Oct. 25 / Oregon Local News / Analyzes the reluctance of doctors to utilize legal exceptions for abortion amid rising maternal deaths, calling for a reevaluation of current practices and highlighting the need for clarity in medical guidelines. “ With the election looming and recent revelations about Amber Nicole Thurman and Candi Miller having lost their lives under the Georgia abortion ban, it is...
Abortion Pills Are Safe. Post-Roe America Isn’t.
Oct. 24 / The New York Times / Calls attention to the alarming trend of hospitals delaying or denying reproductive care in post-Roe America, highlighting the disconnect between medical guidelines and legal repercussions in various states. “ In many states, hospitals are delaying or denying standard reproductive care.
The deaths from abortion bans you won't hear about
Oct. 21 / Salon / Explores the chilling effects of abortion bans on healthcare providers, highlighting fears of legal repercussions. It effectively illustrates the broader implications for maternal health and patient care. “ -- Shares Facebook Twitter Reddit Email Last month, ProPublica published two stories of women who died from abortion bans after the Supreme Court overturned...
Ted Cruz goes quiet on abortion
Oct. 8 / Raw Story / Highlights the paradox of Ted Cruz's silence on abortion amidst a tight election race, revealing the political pressures surrounding reproductive rights. It effectively contrasts Cruz's past advocacy with current hesitations. “ But as reproductive rights loom over the election season as a key issue for voters, Cruz is uncharacteristically quiet. The Texas Republican, running for a...
Supreme Court declines White House appeal in Texas emergency abortion case
Oct. 7 / The Portland Press Herald / Reports on the Supreme Court's decision regarding emergency abortions in Texas, emphasizing the legal complexities and potential dangers posed to women's health, while highlighting the ongoing battle between state and federal law. “ WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Monday let stand a decision barring emergency abortions that violate the law in Texas, which has one of the country’s...
Texas’ abortion laws are straining the OB/GYN workforce, new study shows
Oct. 8 / The Texas Tribune / Analyzes the criminalization of pregnancy in the wake of abortion bans, presenting alarming statistics on prosecutions. It effectively connects historical context with current trends, highlighting systemic issues. “ Sign up for The Brief , The Texas Tribune’s daily newsletter that keeps readers up to speed on the most essential Texas news. Texas’ new abortion laws are...
Supreme Court Lets Texas Ban Emergency Room Abortions
Oct. 7 / Rolling Stone / Examines the Supreme Court's decision allowing Texas to enforce a ban on emergency abortions, critiquing the vague legal exemptions. It underscores the potential life-threatening implications for pregnant women. “ The Supreme Court will allow Texas to enforce a ban on emergency abortions in hospitals. On Monday, the nation’s highest court declined to hear a dispute...
Opinion: Melania Trump says she supports abortion rights. Don't forget what her husband did.
Oct. 8 / Usa Today / Critiques Melania Trump's recent comments on abortion rights, juxtaposing her statements with her husband's policies, and effectively illustrating the political contradictions within the Republican Party. “ We’re four weeks away from the presidential election, and Donald Trump is trying to make the nation forget that he is the one responsible for the fall of Roe...
How We Report on Maternal Health — and How to Get in Touch With Our Team
Oct. 3 / Propublica / Offers a detailed overview of the consequences of abortion bans on healthcare access, emphasizing the chilling effect on doctors. It provides personal stories that humanize the statistics, making the issue relatable. “ It’s clear by now that state abortion bans are having a seismic impact on health care. They are, as intended, preventing doctors from terminating...
The ‘Inconvenience Store’ shows the difficulties of accessing abortion in states with 6-week bans
Oct. 3 / Fast Company / Sheds light on the unique challenges faced by women in states with six-week abortion bans, using a creative project to illustrate the barriers. The approach effectively engages readers while delivering a serious message. “ When you get to the Inconvenience Store website, a banner at the top shares an eerie congratulations: “You’re having an unwanted pregnancy!” Then the urgency...
Oct. 7 / Google News / Provides a concise overview of the Supreme Court's refusal to intervene in Texas's abortion restrictions, noting the implications for women's health and the ongoing legal battles surrounding reproductive rights. “ Supreme Court lets stand a decision barring emergency abortions that violate Texas ban The Associated PressView Full Coverage on Google News
Oct. 3 / Benzinga / Examines the intersection of pregnancy-related prosecutions and the use of medical cannabis, illustrating the complex legal landscape that can lead to criminal charges against women for their choices. “ Over two hundred pregnant women faced criminal charges for conduct related to pregnancy, abortion, pregnancy loss or birth during the first year following...