Summary
The framing of the ongoing conflict between Israel and its adversaries, particularly Hamas and Hezbollah, has significantly evolved over the past year, with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu increasingly portraying the hostilities as a civilizational struggle. This narrative shift reflects not only Netanyahu’s political strategy but also broader changes within Israeli society and politics, as the country grapples with the ramifications of the October 7 attacks and the ensuing war.
In the aftermath of the October 7 attacks, which resulted in the deaths of approximately 1,200 Israelis and the abduction of around 250 hostages, Netanyahu’s government has adopted a more aggressive stance, emphasizing the existential threat posed by Hamas and its allies. This framing has resonated with a significant portion of the Israeli populace, which has experienced profound trauma and loss, leading to a rallying around the government’s military objectives. Analysts note that this narrative has contributed to the empowerment of far-right political factions within Israel, as they advocate for more aggressive military actions and policies aimed at suppressing perceived threats from both Hamas and Hezbollah. The situation has also fostered a sense of urgency among Israeli leaders to respond decisively to these threats, further entrenching the belief that the conflict is not merely a territorial dispute but a battle for survival against forces seeking to undermine Israel’s existence.
Netanyahu’s Civilizational Framing
Netanyahu’s rhetoric has evolved to depict the conflict as a struggle between civilization and barbarism, positioning Israel as a bulwark against terrorism. This characterization has been used to justify extensive military operations in Gaza and Lebanon, with the Prime Minister asserting that the fight against Hamas and Hezbollah is part of a larger battle against Iranian influence in the region. Such statements have been coupled with calls for unity among Israelis, as the government seeks to consolidate support for its military actions and political objectives.
Impact on Israeli Society
The narrative of a civilizational struggle has had significant implications for Israeli society, contributing to a polarized political landscape. As public sentiment has shifted in favor of more hardline policies, the opposition has faced challenges in articulating alternative approaches to security and peace. Demonstrations and public outcry over the handling of hostages have underscored the emotional toll of the conflict, yet they have also been met with a government that frames dissent as undermining national security.
Shift in Political Dynamics
This shift in framing has also altered the political dynamics within Israel, empowering right-wing factions that advocate for aggressive military strategies and a hardline stance against Palestinian groups. The Netanyahu coalition has capitalized on the heightened sense of insecurity and nationalistic sentiment, reinforcing a narrative that emphasizes strength and resilience in the face of adversity. As a result, the Israeli political landscape has become increasingly dominated by voices advocating for a militarized response, sidelining calls for diplomatic solutions or negotiations.
Conclusion
As the conflict enters its second year, Netanyahu’s framing of the hostilities as a civilizational struggle continues to shape both public opinion and political discourse in Israel. This approach not only reflects the immediate security concerns following the October 7 attacks but also signals a deeper transformation in how Israelis view their place in the region and the challenges they face from adversarial forces. The implications of this narrative are likely to influence Israeli policy and society for the foreseeable future.
Middle East latest: Hezbollah says its war with Israel is 'entering a new phase'
Oct. 18 / Abc News / Offers insights into Hezbollah's evolving military capabilities and strategic positioning against Israel, underscoring the complexity of the regional conflict and the implications of recent escalations. “ Lebanon’s Hezbollah militant group said Friday it is entering a new phase in its fight against invading Israeli troops, as the region continued to reckon...
Negotiators around the world can't secure a Gaza cease-fire. These moms want to get it done.
Oct. 14 / Usa Today / Sheds light on the emotional journeys of mothers advocating for the return of their kidnapped children, illustrating the personal stakes involved in the hostage situation and the broader implications for Israeli society. “ Idit Ohel’s son is at the age where young men are building their own lives. Like any mom who wants to help, she went to IKEA for furniture. He loves cooking,...
After 12 months of war, Israel is a changed state, analysts say
Oct. 18 / Al Jazeera / Analyzes the political transformation in Israel after a year of conflict, emphasizing the rise of far-right factions and Netanyahu's increasingly aggressive rhetoric, providing critical insights into shifting dynamics. “ A year of conflict has strengthened the far right and emboldened an increasingly messianic leader, according to analysts. After killing more than 42,000...
What Hamas hoped would happen after Oct. 7
Oct. 15 / The Washington Post / Investigates Hamas's strategic intentions behind the October 7 attack, revealing insights from newly released documents that suggest a desire to incite a broader regional conflict, raising critical questions for Israel. “ As Israel moves ever closer to all-out war with Iran, newly released Hamas documents suggest that this broad regional conflict is precisely what the group’s...
Preserving the stories of the Israel-Gaza conflict through art
Oct. 6 / Cbs News / Highlights the preservation of personal stories and art reflecting the experiences of those affected by the conflict, emphasizing the importance of memory and cultural expression in understanding the ongoing crisis. “ As head of collections at the National Library of Israel, Raquel Ukeles' job took on a new focus, and an emotional turn, after Hamas' massacre last year....
A year later, Israeli survivors reflect on the lingering toll of October 7
Oct. 4 / 6abc / Reflects on the profound emotional and psychological toll of the October 7 attack, providing personal narratives that highlight the lasting impact on survivors and the community's ongoing struggles. “ Lilach Almog walks past the remains of a police station seized by Hamas militants and buildings pockmarked by bullets in her southern Israeli town multiple...
Opinion: Oct. 7 showed me I was wrong about antisemitism in America. It's rampant.
Oct. 7 / Usa Today / Explores the rise of antisemitism in America following the October 7 attacks, providing a personal perspective that underscores the broader societal implications of hate and the need for vigilance against discrimination. “ We were supposed to learn a lesson about the dangers of antisemitism and the depths of evil it can drive from the terror inflicted on Oct. 7, 2023. The world...
Daniel DePetris: A year after Oct. 7, what gains can Israel lay claim to?
Oct. 8 / Chicago Tribune / Analyzes the significant shifts in Israeli policy post-October 7, questioning the effectiveness of military strategies and the political dynamics that have emerged amidst ongoing violence and instability. “ For a state that has experienced many tragedies, Oct. 7 will long be remembered as perhaps the darkest day in Israel’s history. Israelis from across the...
Middle East on verge of wider conflict 1 year after Hamas attacked Israel
Oct. 6 / Abc 15 / Explores the precarious situation in the Middle East a year after the attack, detailing Israel's multifront conflicts while emphasizing the urgent need for security and stability amid escalating tensions. “ Monday will mark one year since Hamas launched a deadly surprise attack in Israel, and now the country is preparing for the possibility of a new attack. More...
One year after October 7 attacks, anger and anguish persist
Oct. 6 / Cbs News / Captures the enduring anger and grief in Israel a year after the October 7 attacks, presenting a stark overview of the conflict's human cost while emphasizing the absence of pathways toward peace. “ One year after October 7 attacks, anger and anguish persist On October 7, 2023, hundreds of Israelis were killed or taken hostage by Hamas terrorists in the...
President Herzog says Israel continues to seek peace with neighbours
Oct. 5 / Yahoo! News / Details President Herzog's commitment to peace while acknowledging the ongoing trauma faced by Israelis, balancing an optimistic vision for the future with the harsh realities of the current conflict landscape. “ Shortly before the first anniversary of the Hamas massacre on October 7, Israeli President Isaac Herzog announced that he intends to overcome hatred in the...
Oct. 7 forever altered the global Jewish existence
Oct. 6 / The Hill / Presents a poignant examination of the psychological impact of the October 7 attacks on the Jewish community, highlighting the enduring trauma and societal changes that have emerged in the wake of the violence. “ In the wake of Hamas’s gruesome attack in Israel, our homes, businesses and places of worship suddenly became targets of hateful acts, slurs, screams of “go...
Oct. 4 / Cbn News ,the Christian Perspective / Offers a counter-narrative to prevailing views on Netanyahu's popularity, showcasing polling data and public sentiment that suggests strong support for his leadership amidst the ongoing crisis, challenging assumptions. “ As the Anniversary of October 7th Approaches, Time to Rethink the Narrative of Netanyahu's 'Unpopularity' Share This article JERUSALEM, Israel – As Israelis...
October 7 Hamas Attacks: How Life Changed at Israel's Borders, One Year On
Oct. 2 / Newsweek / Explores the significant changes in life along Israel's borders post-October 7, offering firsthand accounts that highlight the ongoing challenges faced by residents amidst heightened tensions and security concerns. “ As conflict escalates in the region, Newsweek examines the impact of the past 12 months for residents, defense systems and intelligence.
The United Nations Again Reveals Its True Colors Regarding Israel | Opinion
Sep. 25 / Newsweek / Critiques the UN's handling of the hostage situation and its perceived bias against Israel, raising critical questions about international accountability and the effectiveness of global response mechanisms. “ Over the last year, the failed to bring about the release of ' hostages from 25 countries, refused to hold Hamas accountable for the most grotesque crimes...