Summary
The New Zealand Defense Minister, Judith Collins, has publicly stated that the gender of the captain of the HMNZS Manawanui, which sank off the coast of Samoa, was not a factor in the incident. This statement comes in response to online abuse directed at the female captain following the ship’s sinking during a reef survey mission, which required the rescue of 75 crew and passengers.
Collins emphasized that while the cause of the sinking is still under investigation, it is clear that the captain’s gender did not contribute to the accident. She criticized the online trolling and abusive comments directed at the captain, highlighting the need for decency and respect, particularly towards women in leadership roles. The incident has reignited discussions about the treatment of women in authority in New Zealand, a country known for its progressive stance on gender equality. Collins noted that such behavior is unacceptable and not representative of New Zealand’s values.
Context of the Incident
The HMNZS Manawanui sank on October 6, 2024, while conducting a survey off Upolu, Samoa. All personnel on board were safely evacuated, but the incident has raised concerns about the state of New Zealand’s naval fleet and the challenges faced by its defense forces. Following the sinking, Collins announced that a court of inquiry would be held to determine the cause of the accident, while also addressing the broader implications of the treatment of women in the military.
Response to Online Abuse
Collins’s remarks come amid a broader societal discourse on the treatment of women in positions of power. Despite New Zealand’s historical progress in gender equality, incidents of misogyny and online harassment persist, particularly towards women in uniform. The Defense Minister’s comments serve as a call for accountability and respect, urging the public to refrain from making unfounded judgments based on gender.
Captain’s gender didn’t cause ship to sink, New Zealand minister says
Oct. 10 / Fast Company / Judith Collins' passionate defense of the female captain underscores the need for decency in public discourse, while also reflecting on broader issues of gender equality and the unique challenges faced by women in the military. “ New Zealand’s Defense Minister on Thursday publicly criticized online trolling of the female captain of a naval vessel that sunk at the weekend, saying while...
New Zealand minister condemns ‘misogyny’ over sinking of navy ship
Oct. 10 / Al Jazeera / New Zealand's defense minister's condemnation of online abuse highlights the societal issue of misogyny in leadership roles, offering a strong perspective on the treatment of women in authority. “ New Zealand’s defence minister has condemned online abuse towards the female captain of a navy ship that sank at the weekend. 75 crew and passengers had to...
No evidence of major fuel spill on Samoan reef where New Zealand navy ship sank
Oct. 8 / Abc News / This piece provides critical updates on the sinking incident, including the lack of a major fuel spill, while addressing concerns about New Zealand's aging naval fleet and its operational challenges. “ WELLINGTON, New Zealand -- Divers and marine experts found no evidence of a major fuel spill on a Samoan reef Tuesday after a New Zealand navy ship ran...