Summary
Ongoing lawsuits regarding mail-in ballot counting in Pennsylvania are shaping the electoral landscape as the state approaches the November 2024 presidential election. These legal challenges primarily focus on the requirements for mail-in ballots, including issues related to dating envelopes, the opportunity for voters to correct mistakes (known as “curing”), and the counting of provisional ballots when mail-in ballots are rejected.
The legal disputes have arisen from differing interpretations of Pennsylvania’s voting laws, particularly around the requirement that mail-in ballots must bear a handwritten date on the return envelope. Democrats and voting rights advocates argue that this rule unnecessarily disenfranchises voters, especially since election officials do not use the handwritten dates to track ballot submission times. Conversely, Republicans maintain that adhering to the law as written is essential for maintaining election integrity. Recent rulings have upheld the requirement that ballots must be dated correctly to be counted, but ongoing litigation may influence how these rules are applied on Election Day.
Key Legal Issues
-
Dating Requirement: A significant point of contention is whether ballots should be disqualified for missing or incorrect dates on the outer envelope. Courts have seen conflicting rulings on this matter, with some allowing the counting of undated ballots while others have upheld strict adherence to the dating requirement.
-
Curing Ballots: The legality of allowing voters to correct errors on their mail-in ballots before they are counted is also under scrutiny. Some counties have implemented “notice and cure” policies, which notify voters of issues with their ballots, while others do not. Legal challenges are ongoing regarding whether such practices are permissible under state law.
-
Provisional Ballots: The treatment of provisional ballots—issued when mail-in ballots are rejected—has been another focal point. Recent rulings have indicated that voters whose mail-in ballots are rejected due to technicalities should be allowed to cast provisional ballots that could be counted if no further disqualifying issues arise.
Implications for the Election
The outcomes of these lawsuits are crucial as they could significantly impact voter turnout and the counting of ballots in a state that is expected to play a pivotal role in the presidential election. With polls indicating a close race, even minor changes in how ballots are counted or challenged could sway the final results. The legal landscape remains fluid, and further developments are anticipated as Election Day approaches, potentially leading to more litigation depending on how the counting process unfolds.
Pennsylvania appeals court rules timely mail ballots with improper dates should be counted
Oct. 30 / The Hill / Covers a significant ruling by a Pennsylvania appeals court regarding the counting of mail ballots with improper dates. The article effectively outlines the implications for future elections and voter rights. “ A Pennsylvania appeals court on Wednesday ruled that the state constitution prohibits the disqualification of timely mail ballots because of a missing or...
Understanding Pennsylvania’s undecideds — the voters that could decide the 2024 election
Oct. 29 / Salon / Investigates undecided voters in Pennsylvania, providing a unique on-the-ground perspective that is often overlooked. Its focus on personal interactions adds depth, but the tone may come off as dismissive to some readers. “ -- Shares Facebook Twitter Reddit Email This article originally appeared at TomDispatch . If you’re like many of my friends, I know what you’re thinking:...
The ongoing lawsuits over whose mail-in ballots must be counted in Pennsylvania
Oct. 28 / Npr / Highlights ongoing legal disputes over mail-in ballots in Pennsylvania, emphasizing their potential impact on the upcoming presidential election. The concise analysis provides a clear context for readers. “ Right now, there are several ongoing lawsuits across the state over whose mail-in ballots must be counted. With polls suggesting a tight presidential race,...
GOP challenges Pa. Supreme Court ruling on 'Naked Ballots' case ahead of election
Oct. 26 / Raw Story / Explores the GOP's legal maneuvers against a recent ruling on provisional ballots, showcasing the intricate legal landscape. The article effectively outlines the implications for voters, though it could benefit from clearer organization. “ The Republican National Committee and the Republican Party of Pennsylvania have asked the state’s highest court to delay a ruling that could affect thousands...
Several lawsuits could change how votes are counted in Pa. in November
Oct. 10 / Pennlive / Explores various lawsuits affecting vote counting in Pennsylvania, emphasizing the stakes involved. The article’s thoroughness in outlining legal challenges is commendable, but it could use clearer organization. “ By Katie Bernard, Jeremy Roebuck, The Philadelphia Inquirer (TNS) PHILADELPHIA — With Election Day looming, legal battles shaping how ballots are cast and...
Why the Supreme Court may shy away from 2024 election fights
Oct. 11 / Gazette / Examines the Supreme Court’s likely reluctance to engage in 2024 election disputes, providing a nuanced perspective on judicial involvement. The analysis is well-researched, though it might lack urgency for some readers. “ Despite concerns about the potential for Supreme Court intervention in fights related to the 2024 election , some experts say recent signs suggest the nine...
Nov. 5 election too close to decide mail-in ballot issues: Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Oct. 6 / Raw Story / Covers the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's decisions regarding mail-in ballot rules, highlighting the implications for voter disenfranchisement. The piece is informative, but the legal jargon may confuse some readers. “ In a pair of decisions published Saturday evening the Pennsylvania Supreme Court denied requests to resolve questions about the commonwealth’s vote-by-mail...
Republicans are challenging all aspects of mail-in voting in battleground states
Oct. 8 / Cnn / Highlights ongoing Republican challenges to mail-in voting in Pennsylvania, emphasizing the potential impact on the presidential election. It balances perspectives from both parties, enhancing its credibility and depth. “ After mail-in and absentee voting reached new levels in the 2020 election during the Covid-19 pandemic, a wave of lawsuits over the popular vote-casting...
Republicans lose bid to block Pennsylvania voters from 'curing' mail-in ballots - Reuters
Oct. 7 / Google News / Reports on a Republican setback in blocking ballot curing practices in Pennsylvania, framing it within the larger context of voting rights. The article is straightforward but could benefit from deeper legal analysis. “ Republicans lose bid to block Pennsylvania voters from 'curing' mail-in ballots ReutersPa. Supreme Court will decide if election officials must tell voters...
Voting gets underway in Pennsylvania, as counties mail ballots, open satellite election offices
Oct. 3 / Home | Triblive.com / Voting in Pennsylvania is ramping up as counties mail ballots and open satellite offices, reflecting robust electoral engagement. The article provides essential logistical details, making it a practical resource. “ HARRISBURG — Voting has begun in earnest in the presidential battleground state of Pennsylvania, as counties increasingly begin mailing out ballots, offering...
With Election Day looming, Pennsylvania Republicans close gap with Dems for mail-in ballot requests
Oct. 3 / New York Post / Details the GOP's efforts to close the mail-in ballot gap with Democrats in Pennsylvania, showcasing strategic shifts in their approach. The narrative is engaging, though it may oversimplify complex voter sentiments. “ PITTSBURGH — Just over a month out from Election Day, Keystone State Republicans are closing the gap with Democrats when it comes to voting by mail — despite...
Trump’s 2024 Election Cheat Sheet: Sue, Baby, Sue
Oct. 4 / Usnews / Investigates the strategic legal maneuvers by Trump’s team in battleground states, including Pennsylvania. The article provides a critical perspective on election integrity efforts, though it leans heavily on speculation. “ In the four years since then-President Donald Trump cried election fraud without providing evidence for his false claim, his team has learned a lesson about...
Mail-in ballots mean many will have voted long before election day
Sep. 30 / Home | Triblive.com / Discusses the early mail-in voting landscape in Pennsylvania, detailing logistical preparations and contrasting voter engagement trends. The insights into county-level dynamics offer a practical understanding of voting behavior. “ After a flurry of visits to western Pennsylvania, presidential candidates are running out of time to sway many voters. Pennsylvania election offices already...
Democratic Mail Ballot Requests Outpace Republicans' in Key Swing State
Oct. 2 / Newsweek / Analyzes the disparity in mail ballot requests between Democrats and Republicans in Pennsylvania, offering valuable data that underscores potential electoral outcomes. The statistics are compelling and timely. “ have registered significantly more postal voters than , according to new voter registration data. More than 878,000 Democratic voters have registered for a...