Summary
The topic centers on the testimonies from Robert Card’s family regarding his deteriorating mental state and the subsequent inaction by the Army, which they assert contributed to the tragic mass shooting in Lewiston, Maine. Family members reported concerns about Card’s mental health, including paranoia, delusions, and threats of violence, yet they claim the Army failed to intervene effectively despite being aware of these warning signs.
In the aftermath of the shooting, which resulted in 18 deaths, investigations revealed significant lapses in the Army’s response to the warnings about Card’s mental health decline. Family members testified that they had raised alarms with both military officials and civilian authorities, expressing fears about his behavior, including the creation of a “hit list.” However, these concerns were reportedly downplayed or ignored, leading to a lack of necessary interventions. The Army’s internal investigations indicated that there were numerous opportunities to act on the information provided by Card’s family and fellow service members, yet these opportunities were not utilized effectively.
Key Points from Family Testimonies
- Reported Concerns: Card’s family communicated their worries about his mental state to both his military superiors and civilian authorities, highlighting behaviors such as paranoia and violent ideations.
- Army’s Inaction: Testimonies indicate that despite the family’s warnings, the Army did not take appropriate actions to restrict Card’s access to firearms or to ensure he received mental health treatment.
- Investigative Findings: An independent commission concluded that the Army had ample chances to intervene but failed to act, which may have contributed to the shooting tragedy.
Broader Implications
The testimonies from Card’s family and the findings of subsequent investigations have sparked discussions on the responsibilities of military institutions in managing the mental health of service members. The case raises critical questions about the effectiveness of existing protocols for addressing mental health crises and the obligations of military leadership to act on reported concerns. As the victims’ families pursue legal action against the Army, there is potential for this case to influence future policies regarding mental health support and intervention within military ranks.
Lessons learned, changes made in year after Lewiston shooting
Oct. 25 / Wcvb / Explores the aftermath of the Lewiston shooting, detailing new gun safety measures implemented in response to the tragedy. It provides valuable context on legislative changes and their potential impact on future incidents. “ In the year after Maine's deadliest mass shooting claimed the lives of 18 people and wounded 13 others, a report found missed opportunities to stop the...
Oct. 15 / The Portland Press Herald / Explores the potential for significant changes in military mental health policies as a result of the lawsuit, framing the legal battle within a larger societal context. The discussion on future implications is particularly relevant. “ LEWISTON — When the Army Inspector General finalized an internal investigation into its potential role in the Lewiston mass shooting last fall, they...
Victims of Maine's deadliest shooting take first step toward suing the Army
Oct. 15 / Cbs News / Presents a thorough overview of the victims' legal strategies against the Army, emphasizing the significant emotional toll on families. The balance between legal and personal narratives adds depth to the discussion. “ Lewiston, Maine — Lawyers representing 100 survivors and family members of victims of the deadliest shooting in Maine history have begun the formal process...
Bank of Japan rate hike incoming at the December meeting. Another two in 2025.
Oct. 15 / Forexlive / Calls attention to the formal process initiated by victims' families to hold the Army accountable for failing to intervene regarding Robert Card's mental health. The details on legal steps are compelling. “ Nomura on Japan's economy and the BOJ: Bank of Japan Governor Ueda
General Sir Mike Jackson, former head of the British army, dies at 80
Oct. 15 / The Guardian / Explores the Army's internal investigations, revealing missed opportunities to act on warnings about Card's mental state. The insights into bureaucratic failures provide a critical perspective on military responsibility. “ The soldier was also chief of the general staff and commander of British forces in the 2003 Gulf war
Bob Woodward's newest book is making headlines
Oct. 15 / Npr / Examines the broader implications of the legal action, linking it to ongoing discussions about gun violence and mental health support. The context provided enriches the conversation surrounding military protocols. “ Legendary journalist Bob Woodward's new book War , like so many of his books about the American presidency over the last half century, is generating...
Trump may repeat Hillary Clinton's fatal Electoral College mistake: analysis
Oct. 15 / Raw Story / Discusses the potential for legislative changes that could arise from the lawsuit, framing the legal battle within a larger societal context. The exploration of future implications is particularly relevant. “ Former President Donald Trump owes his presidency to the Electoral College, which elected him despite Trump losing the popular vote in 2016 because of a...
Drones, threats and explosions: Why Korean tensions are rising
Oct. 15 / The Bbc / Reports on the legal claims filed against the Army, detailing the alleged negligence surrounding Card's mental health. The clarity in outlining the legal process makes it accessible to a broad audience. “ North Korea has accused South Korea of flying drones into its capital, ratcheting up tensions that have been simmering for months. The drones allegedly...
US to Israel: No humanitarian aid – no weapons
Oct. 15 / Voanews / Offers a comprehensive overview of the legal actions being pursued by victims' families, detailing the specific allegations against the Army and emphasizing the emotional weight of their testimonies and experiences. “ The U.S. sends a detailed letter warning Israel it must improve the catastrophic humanitarian situation in Gaza within 30 days or risk U.S. military aid. We...
California and Nevada will vote on amending constitution to end forced labor for prisoners
Oct. 15 / Gazette / Discusses the Army's internal investigations and findings, focusing on the critical lapses in communication and action that contributed to the shooting. The insights into bureaucratic failures are particularly revealing. “ Voters in California and Nevada will decide in November if they want to amend their respective constitutions to end forced labor for prisoners . Slavery and...
Oct. 15 / New York Post / Presents a thorough account of Senator Angus King's push for a review of suicide prevention programs for reservists, highlighting systemic issues and the need for better mental health resources within the military. “ BUTLER, Pa. — Democratic billionaires can’t stand her . Republican members of Congress can’t stop investigating her. But President Biden’s Federal Trade...
New Hezbollah leader vows to 'hurt the enemy' in WW3 warning to Israel
Oct. 15 / Daily Express Us / Highlights the emotional weight of the victims' families' statements, underscoring the profound impact of the shooting. It effectively conveys the urgency for accountability and systemic change. “ Hezbollah's acting leader declared Tuesday that the Lebanese militant group is focused on "hurting the enemy" by targeting Haifa and other parts of Israel,...
Angus King asks watchdog agency to review suicide prevention programs for reservists
Oct. 9 / Bangor Daily News / Analyzes the legal claims against the Army, outlining the specific failures that led to the shooting. The clarity in presenting the legal process enhances understanding of the complex issues at stake. “ U.S. Sen. Angus King of Maine wants a congressional watchdog agency to review the adequacy of suicide prevention and response programs for military...
Oct. 8 / New York Post / Investigates the implications of the Army's inaction on mental health issues, linking it to the tragedy. The focus on military accountability is critical, though the article could delve deeper into solutions. “ Furious Joe Biden regrets choosing Attorney General Merrick Garland to lead the Justice Department after the agency prosecuted his son Hunter, a new book by...
Is a New Nuclear Arms Race Inevitable?
Oct. 1 / Oil Price / Details the emotional testimonies from victims' families, emphasizing their calls for accountability and change. The piece effectively conveys the urgency of addressing mental health issues in the military context. “ "For the first time since the Cuban missile crisis, we have a direct threat to the use of nuclear weapons.... We have not faced the prospect of Armageddon...