Summary
Senate Republicans have once again blocked the Right to IVF Act, a bill aimed at establishing federal protections for in vitro fertilization (IVF) and requiring insurance coverage for fertility treatments. This marks the second time this year that the legislation has failed to advance, with a procedural vote of 51-44 falling short of the 60 votes needed.
The recent vote, held on September 17, 2024, was a strategic move by Senate Democrats to highlight the GOP’s stance on reproductive rights ahead of the upcoming elections. The Right to IVF Act, introduced by Senator Tammy Duckworth, seeks to ensure that individuals have access to IVF and that insurance companies cover the associated costs. The bill was partly a response to a controversial ruling by the Alabama Supreme Court that classified embryos as children, raising concerns about the future of IVF access in states with similar legal interpretations. Despite claims from some Republicans, including former President Donald Trump, asserting support for IVF, nearly all Senate Republicans opposed the bill, with only Senators Lisa Murkowski and Susan Collins voting in favor.
Context of the Vote
The backdrop for this legislative effort is a growing debate surrounding reproductive rights in the United States, particularly following the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade. This has led to increased scrutiny on issues such as IVF, which some fear could be impacted by anti-abortion legislation. Senator Duckworth has articulated that the Right to IVF Act is essential not just for individual rights but also to preempt state-level restrictions that could jeopardize fertility treatments.
Political Implications
The blocking of the IVF bill serves as a critical point of contention in the ongoing political discourse. Democrats are framing the issue as a litmus test for Republican support of reproductive health, leveraging it to mobilize voters concerned about access to fertility treatments. As the November elections approach, both parties are keenly aware that reproductive rights are a pivotal issue for many voters, particularly women, which could influence the balance of power in the Senate.
Republican Position
Republican leaders, including Senate Minority Whip John Thune, have dismissed the bill as a “show vote,” asserting that their party supports IVF but disagrees with the specific legislative approach taken by Democrats. This sentiment was echoed by other GOP senators who argued that the bill was unnecessary and politically motivated. However, the repeated failure to support comprehensive IVF protections raises questions about the sincerity of Republican claims regarding their commitment to reproductive health issues.
Fox News Host Confronts Republican Senator on Voting Against IVF
Sep. 29 / Newsweek “ Fox News host Shannon Bream confronted Senator Katie Britt, an Alabama , on Sunday about her voting against a bill that would federally protect access to in...
Kamala Harris, Tim Walz Lose Ground With Women Voters in Minnesota
Sep. 23 / Newsweek “ A new poll of Minnesota voters found that former President may be winning back support from some women, while Vice President has won over some male voters....
Democrats Have Half Billion Ad Spending Advantage Over Republicans
Sep. 23 / Dailycaller “ Republicans and their allies are running approximately $500 million behind Democrats in ad spending running from August until election day, according to a...
For Duckworth, access to IVF is personal
Sep. 18 / Buffalonews “ WASHINGTON – When Sen. Tammy Duckworth put off having children to prioritize her military career, the risk of losing her fertility because of combat injuries...
How every senator voted on the Right to IVF Act, again
Sep. 17 / The Washington Post “ The Senate on Tuesday afternoon voted for the second time this year not to advance a bill that would establish federal protections for in vitro fertilization...
Senate Republicans again block legislation to guarantee rights to IVF
Sep. 18 / Voanews “ Republicans have blocked for a second time this year legislation to establish a nationwide right to in vitro fertilization, arguing that the vote is an...
Senate Republicans block IVF bill, as Democrats elevate issue ahead of November election
Sep. 17 / Npr “ Senate Republicans blocked a Democratic bill to provide a nationwide right to IVF treatments. It was the second time Senate Democrats tried and failed to...
Senate Republicans Block IVF Protection Bill, Despite Trump Claiming He’s a ‘Leader on IVF’
Sep. 17 / Rolling Stone “ On Tuesday, Senate Republicans blocked passage of the Right to IVF Act — a bid by Democrats that would federally protect access to in vitro fertilization...
Democrats block Cruz attempt to pass GOP IVF bill
Sep. 17 / The Hill “ Democrats on Tuesday blocked an attempt by Republican Sens. Ted Cruz (Texas) and Katie Britt (Ala.) to pass a GOP IVF access bill through unanimous consent,...
Senate GOP blocks IVF bill again as Democrats spotlight issue ahead of elections - CNN
Sep. 17 / Google News “ Senate GOP blocks IVF bill again as Democrats spotlight issue ahead of elections CNNDemocrats block Cruz attempt to pass GOP IVF bill The HillSenate...
After all that talk, Senate Republicans block bill to protect IVF
Sep. 17 / Dailykos “ On Tuesday, Senate Republicans successfully blocked a bill that would have provided legal protections for fertility treatments as well as required insurance...
Schumer revives Dem-backed IVF bill after Trump proposal
Sep. 16 / Fox News “ Former President Trump defends his position on IVF during the ABC News Presidential Debate. (Courtesy: ABC News) Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer,...
Democrats block Cruz attempt to pass GOP IVF bill - The Hill
Sep. 17 / Google News “ Democrats block Cruz attempt to pass GOP IVF bill The HillDemocrats Block Cruz-Britt Effort to Pass Nationwide IVF Protection Senator Ted CruzSenate GOP...
Schumer announces Senate to vote on IVF bill a second time Tuesday
Sep. 16 / Gazette “ Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) announced a Tuesday vote on an in vitro fertilization bill that resembles a proposal from former President Donald...
Republicans sink IVF bills. Again.
Sep. 17 / The Hill “ Presented by Plan B One Step — Republicans derided the bill as a show vote {beacon} Health Care Health Care The Big Story Republicans sink IVF bills. Again....