Footage of NYPD officers shooting a man with a knife in a subway station, resulting in injuries to multiple individuals, and subsequent responses from city officials and police reform advocates.

On September 17, 2024, Derell Mickles was confronted by NYPD officers after he allegedly jumped a subway turnstile and brandished a knife. Bodycam footage reveals that the officers shot Mickles while he was standing still, contrary to police claims that he charged at them. The shooting not only injured Mickles but also critically wounded a bystander, Gregory Delpeche, who was struck by a stray bullet. Following the release of the video, there has been significant backlash from advocates for police reform, who argue that the incident highlights systemic issues in how law enforcement handles situations involving mental illness and poverty.

Police Response

NYPD officials have defended the officers’ actions, stating that they attempted to deescalate the situation and resorted to deadly force only when necessary. Interim Commissioner Thomas Donlon emphasized that Mickles refused to comply with orders to drop the weapon. Police Chief John Chell labeled the event a “tragic situation,” asserting that the officers acted to protect themselves and the public.

Legal and Community Reactions

Mickles has pleaded not guilty to multiple charges, including attempted aggravated assault on a police officer. His attorney has raised concerns about the use of excessive force, while community advocates have criticized the police response as indicative of broader issues in policing practices. Mayor Eric Adams initially praised the officers for their restraint but later acknowledged the need for a thorough review of the incident.